As of 21 November 2026, the response has been non-implementation in practice: Can Atalay remains imprisoned and has not been enabled to take his parliamentary seat. However, I could not verify a new Turkish court ruling expressly rejecting the ECtHR’s 17 November judgment, or a substantive public response to it from Erdoğan or the Justice Ministry. That distinction matters: the documented judicial refusals concern the earlier Constitutional Court rulings, not yet a separately documented rejection of this week’s Strasbourg judgment. Reports published this morning still describe Atalay calling from prison for implementation.[elipshaber][izgazete]

What has happened since the ECtHR ruling?
- No release or restoration of parliamentary duties has been reported in the sources I found. In his statement published on 21 November, Atalay demanded an end to “bureaucratic delaying tactics” and asked to be released without further delay so that he could participate in parliamentary work. That is his characterization of the authorities’ conduct, rather than a published judicial explanation for the delay.[izgazete]
- No clear government explanation has emerged in that reporting. Courthouse News reported on the day of the judgment that the Turkish government had not responded to its request for comment. I found no subsequently reported substantive official response in the coverage reviewed through today.[courthousenews]
- Pressure for implementation has instead come from outside the government. TİP leader Erkan Baş called on Parliament Speaker Numan Kurtulmuş to restore Atalay’s parliamentary registration and enable his release and oath-taking. On 19 November, the Union of Turkish Bar Associations and Istanbul Bar Association also demanded implementation and release.[en.haberler][cumhuriyet.com][cumhuriyet.com]
What position had the judiciary and government already taken?
The Turkish judiciary is not acting as a single institution here. The Constitutional Court ordered remedies in Atalay’s favour; the Court of Cassation and the criminal-court process blocked their implementation.[hudoc.echr.coe]
The sequence was:
- In October 2023, the Constitutional Court found that Atalay’s continued imprisonment after his election violated his rights and ordered his release, reopening of proceedings and a stay.
- The Court of Cassation refused to comply and filed criminal complaints against the Constitutional Court judges who supported the ruling.
- The Constitutional Court issued another ruling in December 2023. The Court of Cassation again refused implementation in January 2024.
- Parliament terminated Atalay’s mandate on 30 January 2024. The Constitutional Court subsequently found that the purported removal lacked a valid legal basis, but this did not return him to parliamentary work.[hudoc.echr.coe][stockholmcf][dulger.av]
The government’s legal defence before Strasbourg is particularly revealing. According to the ECtHR’s official summary, Turkey argued that, because the Court of Cassation had not approved the Constitutional Court decisions, Atalay’s conviction remained valid and his imprisonment remained lawful. The ECtHR rejected that reasoning: it effectively made binding Constitutional Court judgments dependent on approval by the very courts required to implement them.[hudoc.echr.coe]
The ECtHR also considered earlier statements by Erdoğan and his chief adviser supporting the Court of Cassation’s stance. Those were part of the background to its finding of a political purpose behind Atalay’s continued imprisonment—not statements responding to the new ECtHR judgment.[hudoc.echr.coe][birgun]
Discover more from Erkan's Field Diary
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
