
I saw an X post claiming Israeli involvement in spreading disinformation related to the French protests. The post’s central claim has independent corroboration: an AI-generated image falsely presented as evidence of violence during the French protests originated with a pro-Israel outlet and then circulated widely. But “Israel-based disinformation” needs an important qualification: the reporting establishes the image’s source and misleading dissemination, not an Israeli government-directed operation or a coordinated network physically based in Israel. The key distinction is attribution.[france24][bbc.co]
What Macías’s post alleges
The indexed text of Julián Macías Tovar’s post reads:
“Cuentas israelís difunden masivamente una imagen hecha por IA de manifestantes franceses dejando desnudos a ancianos.”
That is: “Israeli accounts are massively spreading an AI-made image of French demonstrators stripping elderly people.” I could retrieve the indexed text, but X did not allow me to open the full post directly, so I cannot independently assess every example or account shown in his thread.[x]
What independent reporting confirms
1. The image is fabricated—not a photograph documenting the protests
France 24’s Observers and Full Fact examined images supposedly showing an elderly couple stripped to their underwear during the unrest. Both concluded that the circulating images were AI-generated. Consequently, they cannot serve as photographic evidence that protesters committed this attack.[france24][fullfact]
More decisively than visual anomalies or automated detection alone, BBC Verify obtained an acknowledgment from the source: Sabrina Hania, director of Infos-Israel.News, said her team created the image using ChatGPT, without a reference photograph, and published it on October 17.[bbc.co]
2. A pro-Israel publisher is a documented source
France 24, working with the European Broadcasting Union’s Spotlight network and Belgium’s RTBF fact-checkers, traced one image to a montage published by the pro-Israel account Infos-Israel.news late on October 17. Full Fact likewise identified an October 17 montage as the earliest version it found.[france24][fullfact]
That supports a specific, demonstrable connection to a pro-Israel publisher. It does not, by itself, establish where every operator or subsequent amplifying account was physically located.
3. The original carried an AI label; subsequent sharing removed that context
According to the BBC, the original was labelled “Made with AI” on X and “AI content” on Instagram. It was subsequently shared on X without that disclaimer in a post receiving more than six million views. Hania said she regretted that it had misled people and blamed those who reshared it without identifying its artificial origin.[bbc.co]
This matters for the terminology: the evidence establishes misleading circulation of synthetic imagery. Whether the original publisher deliberately intended deception is a separate question; its initial AI disclosure complicates that allegation. Removing the disclosure and presenting the image as an actual photograph is the clearer evidentiary problem.[bbc.co]
4. The underlying assault allegation remains unverified
The story did not originate solely with the image. BFMTV journalist Dominique Rizet reported an alleged attack on an elderly couple, citing a police source. But the Paris prosecutor’s office told Libération’s CheckNews that, as of October 19, it had received no reports corresponding to the alleged incident. France 24 and Full Fact therefore treated the attack itself as unconfirmed.[france24][fullfact]
These are two separate findings:
- The purported photographic evidence is fabricated.
- The alleged assault was not independently confirmed in the reporting reviewed; that is not the same as conclusively proving that no assault occurred.[france24][fullfact]
How far does “Israeli disinformation” hold up?
| Claim | Assessment from the available evidence |
|---|---|
| A fake image circulated about the French unrest. | Confirmed by independent fact-checking and the creator’s acknowledgment. [france24][bbc.co] |
| A pro-Israel outlet created and published one widely circulated image. | Confirmed: Infos-Israel.News is the documented source. [france24][bbc.co] |
| It spread widely with misleading claims. | Confirmed: the BBC documented an unlabelled repost with more than six million views; France 24 documented inflammatory accompanying narratives. [france24][bbc.co] |
| The amplifiers were all Israeli or physically based in Israel. | Not established by these investigations; France 24 also describes amplification by far-right accounts. [france24] |
| This was a coordinated Israeli state operation. | Not established by the image investigations. Their findings identify a publisher and a dissemination pathway, not government direction. [france24][bbc.co] |
Independent investigations traced a viral AI-generated image about the French unrest to the pro-Israel outlet Infos-Israel.News. Initially labelled as AI-generated, it was subsequently circulated without that disclosure and used to support inflammatory claims about protesters and migrants. This documents misleading amplification linked to a pro-Israel publisher, but does not establish an Israeli state-directed disinformation campaign.[france24][bbc.co][fullfact]

Other false narratives spread about the protests
Beyond the fabricated elderly-couple image, fact-checkers documented several other false narratives: an immigrant-led “civil war,” attacks on Christians, catastrophic destruction in Paris, and unrelated footage repackaged as current rioting. The important distinction is between invented events, genuine footage falsely captioned, and political accusations that lack evidence.[inquirer][france24][leadstories]
1. “France is experiencing an anti-white civil war”
France 24 documented Alex Jones promoting an “anti-white civil war” narrative, including claims of “dead bodies everywhere.” Its October 5 investigation found no evidence for those allegations and reported that no deaths had been recorded in the protests at that point. The demonstrations concerned school conditions—including teacher shortages, overcrowded classes and deteriorating facilities—not an organised racial uprising.[france24]
One piece of purported evidence was a burning school bus. The footage actually showed a bus fire in Nîmes in 2022, with no casualties reported, rather than an attack during the current demonstrations. This was authentic footage given a false political and temporal context.[france24]
2. “Migrants and Islamists are responsible for the riots”
Posts and political commentary presented the violence as proof that immigrants or Muslims had overrun France. An Associated Press fact-check found that authorities and police had not linked immigrants collectively to the rioting; the exact sociological composition of those involved was not established. It also found no direct link between the violence and religious faith.[inquirer]
That does not mean every participant’s identity is known, or that no immigrant participated. It means the collective-blame narrative goes beyond the available evidence. AP also distinguished the involvement of some radical far-left activists from the unsupported claim that they accounted for all the violence.[inquirer]
3. “Christians, churches and clergy are being systematically attacked”
France 24 examined claims about an organised campaign against Catholic institutions or clergy and found that the videos offered as evidence did not substantiate them. AP subsequently reported that no houses of worship had been directly attacked in the unrest it examined. These findings undermine the portrayal of the protests as a religious persecution campaign.[inquirer][france24]
4. “These videos show the destruction happening now”
Several widely shared clips were real—but showed different events:
| What viewers were told | What fact-checkers established |
|---|---|
| Smoke and crowds around the Eiffel Tower showed that “France has fallen.” | The footage showed Paris Saint-Germain supporters celebrating the club’s Champions League victory in May, not the student protests. [france24] |
| A clip of confrontations showed the current student demonstrations. | AFP traced it to the January 19, 2023 pension-reform protest and obtained confirmation from the person who filmed it. [factcheck.afp] |
| Overturned, burning vehicles showed damage from the current school protests. | AFP traced the footage to Paris protests on December 24, 2022. [factcheck.afp] |
| A viral fireworks confrontation showed the latest French unrest. | Reporting identified the scene as protests in Tbilisi in 2024, not France. [news.liga] |
| People shown in a video were looters in Paris. | Lead Stories identified the footage as Madrid street vendors and found that it predated the French rioting. [leadstories] |
The mechanism here is not necessarily fabrication of the video itself: it is the substitution of a new date, location or explanation. That can make genuine violence appear more extensive or geographically widespread than the evidence supports.[france24][factcheck.afp][factcheck.afp]
5. “The Eiffel Tower is burning”—and other fabricated landmark scenes
Lead Stories examined a viral clip supposedly showing the Eiffel Tower being destroyed by fire. It found that live Paris webcams showed the landmark unharmed; AI-detection results also supported the finding that the clip was synthetic.[leadstories]
The same fact-checking outlet examined a purported video of Palestinian and Jordanian flags atop the tower. Its analysis identified disproportionate figures and other indications of AI generation. This was another invented Paris scene, not documentary evidence of protesters taking over the landmark.[leadstories]
6. “The Pink Panther has become a real protest figure”
Images and videos purportedly showing a Pink Panther-costumed demonstrator fighting police, being arrested or confronting officers also circulated. Lead Stories found that examples were AI-generated or manipulated from older photographs. One underlying photograph came from protests in Armenia in 2015; another showed a police detention during PSG celebrations on May 31, 2025.[leadstories]
Some of this material may have been produced as humour rather than as a serious political allegation. Nevertheless, the scenes were not authentic records of the current protests. The investigation’s strongest evidence was its tracing of the underlying photographs, rather than AI-detector scores alone.[leadstories]
7. “Foreign powers organised the riots”
This requires a different verdict: not a demonstrated fact, rather than a conclusively disproved possibility.
Reporting has identified foreign-linked exploitation and amplification of the unrest. France 24 reported Alliance4Europe’s findings about pro-Russian accounts amplifying anger before the protests, based on analysis of more than half a million posts. But Euronews distinguished this from proof that foreign governments initiated or directed the violence; it reported that conclusive evidence for that stronger allegation was lacking.[france24][euronews]
Discover more from Erkan's Field Diary
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
