In nine episodes (you can find them here), I have focused on some characteristics of the current academic life that is killing the university system -not any more- slowly: Nine episodes of administrative bloat, ranking obsessions, funding regimes that reward the wrong things, accreditation rituals nobody quite believes in, a journal hierarchy that has turned curiosity into a points system, and a hiring process that asks you to perform transparency while withholding almost everything that matters.

Most of our critical focus concerns the current state of the university system, which can be characterized as a neoliberal institution. However, the idea of university is beyond this: As a form of social organization, a particular and genuinely strange way that human societies have devised for producing, protecting, and transmitting knowledge across generations. That form predates the rankings and will likely outlast them. It’s the one worth defending.
I will continue to demonstrate other sickening characteristics of academic life, but it is time for a turn. Why do we still need academia? Why I care to documenting the decline? So, starting with this episode, I will attempt to articulate why I still believe in academic knowledge, without a necessary hierarchical order.
This is where I part ways with the two most obvious but still valuable guides. Stefan Collini (2012) wants to defend the university by returning to something like its older, more humane self. But that reading is too elegiac for my taste, too in love with a version of the institution that was never as available to most of the world as it was to Cambridge. Martha Nussbaum (2016) wants to defend it as the training ground for democratic citizenship through the humanities. This is closer to what I believe, but still assumes a liberal-humanist subject and a liberal-democratic context that a lot of the world’s universities have never actually had the luxury of assuming. These powerful and classical do not imagine the university as it has existed in the postcolony, or under authoritarian pressure, or as an import that had to be translated, resisted, and remade by the societies that inherited it.
I will attempt to imagine the university as an anthropological fact, a durable and portable institutional form that keeps reappearing under radically different political conditions because it does something no other arrangement quite does. [And yet another topic for another episode emerges here as I write these: What is the difference between university and academia? That’s for another episode]
I will begin with this: The Gift of Slow Time
Nearly every major institution in modern society runs on a clock that the university, at its best, refuses to keep. The market wants a return this quarter. Venture capital wants an exit in five years. Journalism wants the story today, ideally before the competition. The university is close to the only institution left that can say, with something like legitimacy, this might matter in forty years — and it might not, and we’re going to study it anyway.
This isn’t romanticism. It’s how a great deal of what we now depend on actually got made. Einstein’s work on the photoelectric effect wasn’t chasing an application; it was a young patent clerk taking a strange feature of light seriously. Non-Euclidean geometry sat for the better part of a century as an elegant, apparently useless correction to Euclid – until it turned out to be exactly the mathematics general relativity needed. CRISPR began as an unglamorous question about how bacteria remember viruses that once infected them; nobody funding that work was thinking about gene editing. In every case, the distance between the question and its consequence was decades, and nobody could have shortened it by wanting an answer faster.
Robert Merton described the norms that make this kind of science possible – communalism, universalism, disinterestedness, organized skepticism — and it’s worth noticing how much slow time each of them silently requires. Disinterestedness is nearly impossible on a two-year funding cycle, where you have every incentive to find what your funder hoped you’d find. Organized skepticism -the willingness to let your own result be picked apart, possibly for years, before anyone trusts it -doesn’t survive contact with a job market that rewards speed of publication over durability of claim. These norms weren’t designed for our moment. They were designed for a slower one, and they degrade when the clock speeds up.
Helga Nowotny gives us useful language here: Mode 1 knowledge, discipline-driven, slow, accountable mainly to the question itself; and Mode 2, application-driven, fast, accountable to whoever is paying for the answer. Both have their place. But a university system that has fully surrendered to Mode 2 has quietly given up the thing that used to distinguish it from a consultancy. Maggie Berg and Barbara Seeber make a related point at the level of daily practice in The Slow Professor -that time itself, unhurried reading, unhurried thinking, is not a luxury sitting outside the intellectual work but is the infrastructure the work is built on. Take the time away and you don’t just get slower work. You get a different, thinner kind of work.
Innovation studies has a name for the gap in between: the valley of death, the long, uncertain stretch between a basic discovery and any application anyone can point to. What crosses that valley is almost never the fast, applied, well-funded project. It’s the patient, curiosity-driven research that nobody was watching closely enough to rush.
Now we have LLMs: the fastest knowledge machines we have ever built to instantly, on demand, recombine and pattern-match across everything that has already been thought. What they cannot do, at least not yet, is produce the kind of conceptual rupture that comes from someone sitting with a strange, apparently useless question for fifteen years. Fast knowledge and slow knowledge aren’t the same thing, pursued at different speeds. They may be different things entirely.
Unfortunately, the university system is forced to operate under increasingly faster times. We need to realize how fast we should go, not because we cannot, but do we really need to?
References
Berg, M., & Seeber, B. K. (2016). The slow professor: Challenging the culture of speed in the academy. University of Toronto Press.
Collini, S. (2012). What are universities for?. Penguin UK.
Gibbons, M., Limoges, C., Nowotny, H., Schwartzman, S., Scott, P., & Trow, M. (1994). The new production of knowledge: The dynamics of science and research in contemporary societies. Sage Publications.
Merton, R. K. (1973). The normative structure of science. In N. W. Storer (Ed.), The sociology of science: Theoretical and empirical investigations (pp. 267–278). University of Chicago Press. (Original work published 1942)
Nowotny, H., Scott, P., & Gibbons, M. (2001). Re-thinking science: Knowledge and the public in an age of uncertainty. Polity Press.
Nussbaum, M. C. (2016). Not for profit: why democracy needs the humanities. Princeton University Press.
Discover more from Erkan's Field Diary
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
