A few more words on the "Kurdish Opening"

Well, Turkish political agenda is full of new openings and summer was not a vacation time. Alas, I was in a sort of vacation and thus missed blogging about these openings (and crises, of course).

Brief ideas on the Kurdish opening:

1) High officials in the Turkish army backs the gov’t move. Without that backing, I do not believe AKP would be courageos enough to declare the move.

2) In the last elections, AKP realized that there is no way it can win hearts of CHP voting masses in Western, and Southern parts of Anatolia. Plus, despite the dose of rising nationalism, AKP lost votes to nationalist MHP in Central Anatolian towns. On the other hand, in Kurdish lands, AKP has a real chance. This opening may win some extra votes. This opening might be a "revenge" against nationalist Turks.

3) Nationalist reactions stayed at a ridiculous level. MHP leader’s too angry rhetoric reaches to absurdity instead of substantive opposition. CHP is already in an absurd situation since it now rejects what it had proposed as solution to Kurdish crisis decades ago…

Turkish army officers salute flag-covered coffin of Orhan Kilic, ...
Turkish army officers salute flag-covered coffin of Orhan Kilic, one of nine Turkish soldiers killed by Kurdish rebels of the Kurdistan Workers Party or PKK at the Turkey-Iraq border two days ago, during a funeral service at the Kocatepe Mosque in Ankara, Turkey, Thursday, Sept. 10, 2009.
(AP Photo/Burhan Ozbilici)

But of course, those opposing the opening, were quick to manipulate the funeral of killed Turkish soldiers… No surprise; hawks of both sides do not like an opening.

In the mean time, another opening comes with the Armenian side. And yet another comes with the EU as the wise men talk. Unfortunately, the gov’t scores miserably against the media. Even I am getting angry with gov’t moves against the Doğan Media Group. All about these can be found below…

 

Between social integration and political dissociation: Turkey’s Kurdish issue perception (1) by TAHA ÖZHAN

On Sept. 11, Armenian massacres, butterflies, the caliphate and the EU

 

 

 

 by ORHAN KEMAL CENGİZ

Turkey hopeful on Armenia border

Read more

After Obama

There is of course a huge flow of journalistic production. This is just a small bite. Unfortunately, I don’t have time to collect more links. In the very end, there are also a few links I had collected under the category "americana".

Taking it to the Kids


I had the chance yesterday to attend Barack Obama’s town hall meeting with some 100 Turkish university students. The event was broadcast live on Turkish television and seemed to me like another successful public diplomacy effort, particularly in a country where America’s image (or at least that of the American government) had sunk very low. Obama clearly has star power — "I love him!" one young woman told me — but listened carefully to the students’ questions and delivered serious, but down to earth, answers.

Read more

Franco-German pressure on Turkey for the NATO chief selection…

I am watching the discussion on Turkey’s opposition against Mr. Rasmussen’s candidacy to head NATO in NTV news channel. It seems that even the former diplomats whom PM Erdoğan does not like, are supporting Turkey’s opposition… 

Anders Fogh Rasmussen at the Nato summit, 3 April

BBC: Anders Fogh Rasmussen had been the odds-on favourite

It looks like major EU powers were not too diplomatic; they nominated Mr. Rasmussen  without getting consent of Turkey. Turkey may not be a major power in EU but a major contributor in NATO. She probably contributed for NATO more than Germany and France did together. Here in Turkey, a consensus emerges: Franco-German alliance is an ill-intentioned move to isolate Turkey and weakend the already weakend TR-EU relations.Turkey accuses Mr. Rasmussen not being able to handle Danish Cartoon crisis but also ROJ TV’s position. ROJ TV is a TV channel organically linked with PKK and the channels still broadcasts from Denmark. Turks are probably angrier because of that and Cartoon crisis comes only as a second issue…

With the support of domestic consensus, PM Erdoğan may not give in. Today will be an exciting day for the news junkies:)

Turkey blocks Denmark’s Nato hopes

Turkey has blocked Europe’s candidate to head Nato, souring a summit marking the military alliance’s 60th anniversary and opening a new rift between Ankara

Read more

Obama will be in town- soon

Classy advertising magazine MediaCat has this cover for April. In my Facebook news-stream, I observe a reaction from Kemalist friends. They call for a protest against the magazine because it replaces Atatürk’s face from this classical photo in which Atatürk teaches the new alphabet to citizens…Title says "An educating leader and his constituency"

 

 an older roundup follows:

 

Read more

President Gül's historical visit to Iraq; another taboo broken

Turkey’s President Abdullah Gul (L) and his wife Hayrunnisa Gul (C) pose with Iraq’s President’s Jalal Talabani and his wife Hero Ibrahim Ahmed (2nd L) during a welcoming ceremony at Salam Palace in Baghdad March 23, 2009. Talabani said on Monday the Turkish separatist guerrilla group Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) must lay down its arms or leave Iraqi soil. The comments by Talabani, a Kurd, were some of the toughest made recently by an Iraqi leader against PKK rebels, who have used northern Iraq as a base to launch attacks in Turkey, straining ties between Baghdad and Ankara.REUTERS/Mohammed Jalil/Pool (IRAQ POLITICS)

 Apart from the expected protesting cries from die-hard nationalists or opposition, I observe that there is even a relief. Finally we did. Turkey had to recognize the regional Kurdish government in Northern Iraq and had to start relations with it. Even in pragmatic terms, this could be the next stage. Finally, Turkish State initiates a new era, in the mean time, the President uses the word "Kurdistan". I don’t personally believe this recognition helps separatists. It is an initiative for a friendly era. Separatists might even be upset. Because all parties, all hawks from all sides, seemed to have relied on some nonnegotiable positions. What to do with a not hostile but friendly Turkey? 

Yet another taboo dies in ’Kurdistan’

ANKARA – President Abdullah Gül’s first official uttering of the word ’Kurdistan’ in relation to the regional administration in northern Iraq sends shockwaves through the opposition, which fears this could encourage calls for more concessions and reveals foreign meddling.

Read more

"Turkish PM Erdogan confirms U.S. President Obama visit on April 6-7

The New Wave of Foreign Policy Activism in Turkey

DIIS This 40-page Danish report investigates continuities and ruptures in Turkish foreign policy, with special reference to Europeanization

 

A round up in Turkish foreign policy… 

Read more

Warm days for US-Turkey relations

Clinton’s visit and then Obama’s would be visit in a month are perceived as a sign for better days between these two countries. It is yet to be seen whether Mr. Obama will take Turkey to talk to Islamic World. I believe it is still early to think Turkey as the heart of Islamic World. Turkey’s new foreign policy aims at that but Turkey is still alien to most of the Islamic World. But who will represent the "Islamic World"? Saudi Arabia is moving to the leadership of Middle Eastern Arabic countries but that does not represent Islamic World itself. An Islamic World possible? There certainly a problem of representation…

Read more

Anatolian Armenians in 1915

Mavi Boncuk provides us a National Geography article on Anatolian Armenians that was published back in 1915…

ARMENIA AND THE ARMENIANS by Hester Donaldson Jenkins

By M.A.M



What really happened in 1915?. 1915 Article in National Geographic is quite a source. The article was written by a professor at the American College for Girls in Constantinople from 1900-1909……

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A round up on Turkish foreign policy and EU process related issues follows: 

Read more

A round up in Turkey's foreign policy issues…

A German court’s visa regulation about Turkish visitors is notable….

Israeli Chief of Staff officially apologizes because of Gen. Mizrahi’s statements…

Mr. Obama will not likely to use the word "genocide", so that there is less tension between TR-US recently.. 

There more op-eds about Turkey’s new foreign policy attempts and more questions arise whether Turkey leaves the "Western" front or not…

and there is more of course… 

 

Read more

Gen. Mizrahi's big mistake.

Gen. Avi Mizrahi, the head of the Israel Defense Forces’ Ground Forces "issued a tongue-lashing to Turkey’s prime minister to remind the country of past atrocities" in an international meeting. PM Erdoğan was targeted but the way he was targeted involved the Turkish army. In both Armenian question and Kurdish questions, Turkish army feels more involved with the traditional and still official Turkish state discourses. Thus, Gen. Mizrahi angered Chief of Staff more than PM himself, probably. This is not good for Israel because it seems that major relations between Israel and Turkey take place in the field of military relations and now Israel risks these relations. Despite AKP’s distance from Israel, this so far had not extended to a break in military relations – as the staunchly secular Turkish Army plays her own game- but this might change from now on… We will see…

Read more

"Turkey slammed for slowing down reform again

the European Parliament’s foreign affairs committee released its report on Turkey a few days ago. It was expectedly critical. In the mean time, Turkey uses her NATO cards in his foreign policy dealings and of course Middle East affairs remain to be a significant field in Turkish foreign policy that might possibly influence TR-US relations…and CHP has taken anew interest in the EU process. Mr. Baykal paid a visit to Brussels… 

Turkey slammed for slowing down reform again

As it has done on various occasions over the last three years, the European Parliament’s foreign affairs committee yesterday (11 February) expressed concern about a "continuous slowdown of the reform process" in Turkey, in a resolution adopted by overwhelming majority…

Read more

"Stirrings" in the EU process…

Turkey’s EU process seems to have peripherialized in Turkish foreign policy but that does not mean there is no progress. There is at least some "stirring" recently. The new chief negoatiator, Egemen Bağış, whose sole duty will be the negotiation itself will certainly have an impact. There is a huge roundup here on TR’s EU process. Towards the end of the post, there is a roundup on the Davos aftermath. There are a few pieces on linking TR’s EU process to developments in the Middle East. Finally, there is the case of Atilla Olgaç, that I could not cover before. I have to agree with Hans who labelled him as "just another idiot amongst others"……

Read more

What happens on April 25th?

Yuvakuran below urges us to think about what might happen after April 24:

On 24th April 2009 Friday morning, it is most likely that the new US President will make an unavoidable and regrettable speech on so-called genocide, to put fuel on an 100-years old sad historical story in order to please his Armenian voters and to repay his election debt.

And he announced the most likely response:

The day after, we may read that Incirlik Air Base is closed to all foreign access.

New Turkish foreign policy seemed to have decided not to rely on the Jewish lobby in US that had helped prevent the becoming of this scenario before.
One likely idea might be that Turkish leaders believe Turkey has now self-confidence, that she is indispensable in Middle East. So that nothing changes.
But more likely idea is that Mr. Obama may try to bypass Turkey. His special envoy did not even visit Turkey… I do not think US or EU countries give much credit to Turkey at the moment and I am not sure if this is right or wrong but this seems to be the case. Turkey is risking her chances, she might win or not. Mr. Obama may have revolutionary ideas for domestic politics but in foreign policy he might have relied on the overall FP structure. Honestly, the best thing he could do would be not to start another war. We will see. But in the mean time, this dark scenario may happen. That is, the closure of İncirlik Base.

That seems inevitable. AKP cannot act against a sweeping nationalist reaction.

In the mean time, in these tense and but exciting times, your Erkan will be serving his military duty. Yes, it is time. I will write about it soon.  I might miss some but experience some other things. We will see…

The Day After April 24th 2009

By yuvakuran

Dear Energy Professional, Dear Colleagues,

On 24th April 2009 Friday morning, it is most likely that the new US President will make an unavoidable and regrettable speech on so-called genocide, to put fuel on an 100-years old sad historical story in order to please his Armenian voters and to repay his election debt.

The day after, we may read that Incirlik Air Base is closed to all foreign access.

After every US presidential elections, Turkish Ministry of foreign affairs, Turkish armed forces, Turkish media, and Turkish intellectuals have an important task. When the winner is a democrat candidate, we should start to educate the newcomer, and his/her staff/ advisers, what they can expect, what to say, what not to say. ……………

Erdoğan in weekly satire magazine covers:

Read more

Soner Çağaptay's one-man crusade continues…

Mr. Çağaptay has not written a single positive thing about the AKP government in 6 years. He is acting as if a deposed ruler in exile fighting back. His words could be more meaningful if he weren’t such a biased person. His reliance on neo-con anxieties of islamophobia is passé. The only loser in this game is these seemingly credible news media whose space he occupies…There is a quote from his latest bullshitting below. At the very end, there are two bullying views from Jerusalem Post.

In the mean time, Şahin Alpay writes Why do most Turks side with Erdoğan at Davos?

Read more

Reactions to Erdoğan's reaction

 It seems that government had decided not to rely on Jewish lobby in the US. Against the Armenian Genocide claims, Jewish lobby was a constant helper. Israeli officials themselves downplayed the crisis, but not the diaspora.

I believe PM Erdoğan consolidates his domestic power. But I don’t think this was a staged event as some commenters claim. They have wild imaginations. Too much belief in conspiracy theories.

Turkey’s image? Hmmm when was it good anyway? 

 

 

According to a poll, made in 30 cities and 1200 citizens by MetroPoll, 78.3 % agrees with PM Erdoğan’s reaction while 13.7% disagrees.

 

 

 

However, this does not mean, all those agree think this will have good consequences for Turkey. Still, that’s 55.7 %. On the other hand, 21% thinks this is not good for the country.

[roundup updated]

Read more